I think the butterfly and eagle masks would be great for a super hero to wear.  If making the masks for trick or treating, I advise you put them on a stick and allow the children to hold them up to their face at the door.  It is much safer to walk around without a mask on.

Paper Masks

• Butterfly
• Eagle
• Flower
• Handprint Masks
• Jack-O'-Lantern
• Lion

Paper Plate Masks

• Animals
  • Beaver
  • Cow
  • Dog
  • Dragon
  • Duck
  • Elephant
  • Fox
  • Goat
  • Hippopotamus
  • Koala
  • Lion
  • Monkey
  • Panda
  • Parrot
  • Rabbit
  • Racoon
  • Ram
  • Reindeer
  • Rhino
  • Skunk
  • Tiger
  • Zebra
• Geisha
• Football Player
• Frankenstein
• Jester
• Monster (alien)
• Oni (blue)
• Oni (red)
• Pirate
• Scarecrow
• Troll
• Vampire
• Witch